Keeping Us Real
Posted by Liz Thursday Oct 23, 2008We were asked the question about our previous post “A Window of Opportunity”
What’s wrong with the old windows?
My answer started to get so long I decided to make it a post instead of a comment. To answer the question: They’re pretty old, and don’t work well anymore – particularly the storm windows and screens. On some of the windows it’s impossible to pull the storm down. Some don’t even have a storm window, a must here in Chicago. Especially since I don’t fancy putting up plastic sheeting every winter. Some don’t have a screen, another must since mosquitoes are highly attracted to me!
If you look at the current “lastest pics” picture, it shows the backyard, and you can see the metal frames on the windows are pretty unattractive. This is even more true on the front of the house.
For the sunroom, we are cutting in entirely new bigger windows in some places, and so want the rest of the house to match these so they don’t look like such an addition, but are integrated with the rest.
It’s a good question. It made me stop and think for a minute, did we really need that? I think sometimes you get so caught up in remodeling, it can be easy to change things without a purpose or consciously thinking about why. But change for change’s sake is not always improvement.
I enjoyed his post about this at the blog “Keepin’ It Real“ and I agree, that if you can restore you should (hence the many man hours spent restoring the trim around the house). Particularly in these older homes, the stuff around your house is of far better quality than you could get today even if you wanted to spend the money. If our windows were nice wood windows (the kind of casements shown in the windows post), or old counter-weight double hungs we would definitely keep them. I have reglazed and restored windows before with the Martin’s at Greene & Burke, so that is not the daunting task. But ours are aluminum inside and out, were cheap to begin with, and in my opinion, not worth the effort.
October 23rd, 2008 at 7:20 pm
If they are aluminum, they probably aren’t original anyway. Good luck with the replacements!
October 24th, 2008 at 5:09 am
I agree with Jennifer – I wouldn’t sweat pulling the aluminum if they are a mess. Wonder if there is a place that recycles them? It’s too bad you aren’t going back to an original 4-window configuration on the front. This would most likely have been the original pattern where the picture window is. They would make the home look more like a bungalow/cottage than a ranch but I understand why some people like the picture windows and want to keep them. I’m enjoying the blog and can appreciuate the work – particularly dealing with the village’s permit process.
October 24th, 2008 at 7:35 am
I was just thinking today about what to do with the old ones. My ideas so far are seeing if anyone wants them on Craig’s List. Other than that, you probably could recycle them by knocking out the glass and recycling that, and taking the aluminum to the scrap metal place and get back a whopping 10 dollars. But it’s not about the money, it’s about the environment.
And yeah, I like the picture window.
January 2nd, 2009 at 9:27 am
We have plans maybe in the fall of next year to redo the front window along with the front stoop. We aren’t sure if the front window configuration is original but you are probably right that it isn’t quite orginal. Though a number of the houses do have a similar large front window flanked by two double hung windows. The current replacement window probably just mimicked that configuration.